Why a critique group

Joe’s Blog #25

How many of us are part of a critique group?

critEver since I started getting serious about my writing, I’ve been a part of a critique group. Why? It’s made me a better writer. It’s that simple. So here’s why anyone not in one might want to consider being in one. A good one.

1) It’s way cheaper than paying a book doctor or so-called editor to look over your manuscript. For the cost of a few coffees for everyone, maybe a donut or two, you can get great feedback on what works and what doesn’t. (Though, in my group, we get to eat all sorts of amazing food and drink, but this may not be the norm.)

2) They can help spot things you’ll never see. “Joe, did you realize you just used the word ‘nipple’ 32 times on page 212?”

3) They ensure your characters don’t go off script. “So how, for the love of God, could Lou, who has just found love again, who is in the process of rebuilding his life, who clearly is moving forward, suddenly up and decide to go on a suicide mission? Why? Tell me, why, dammit?” (The cool thing here is that I created a character they loved, the bad thing was I made him do something out of character without a better explanation.)

vision-try-to-look-at-things-from-a-different-perspective4) They can give you a perspective you just don’t have. “Ok, you used ‘totally’ way too much in you YA novel. No one talks like that anymore.” Hello!

5) They can give you great ideas. “What if you made the woman at the airfield younger, prettier? What if she secretly loves him?”

6) They can help you fine tune the technical aspects of your writing. “You need a hook out of this chapter.” “You’re using passive language.” “You should stop writing in crayon.”

7) They can help with spelling and grammar. The kind of mistakes you feel silly making. “It’s H-A-N-G-A-R, not hanger!!!”

8) They can point out the things that work. And here’s one of the things that makes a good group, in my opinion. It’s all too easy to tear something down, to rip a writer to shreds. I’ve had it done. It’s like having your baby mauled by a zombie. But if you get a group that can also focus on the positive, that’s gold. “The details are fantastic, it’s like I’m there in Hawaii in the 1930’s.”  “Who knew lighted intersections were not the norm. So cool.”

9) They force you to write. Trust me, no one wants to show up at a session without writing.

10) Last, but not (as they say) least, they provide support. Hey, every one of the writers is going through the same thing, battling the same demons, struggling with the same problems. It’s nice to be able to meet with people who understand what it’s like to agonize over a name or spend hours trying to fix a problem with an imaginary character.

Me? I’m glad to have had some great groups. Each one has helped me become a better writer and, one day, when I finally get published, they can all take a little credit.

I can’t wait to meet back up with my current group.

For other perspectives, check out these links. 10 Benefits of Joining a Writing Group. Benefits of Writing Groups. The Benefits of Joining a Writer’s Group.

Queries Sent: 0 (Ok, somebody shoot me.)

Rejections: 1 (grand total, not this week)

People Currently Critiquing My YA Book: 2

11 thoughts on “Why a critique group

    • Yeah, I kinda got inside my head on the whole query thing, Bev. I kept rewriting it and rewriting it in hopes of making it perfect. And yet, somewhere in that dark part of my brain, I knew it could be never perfect.
      I’ll get some more out tomorrow. 🙂

  1. I’ve alway avoided writer’s groups, being both a loner and an ill-tempered old bastard. But you’ve reinforced some things that Silk told me, and I think there’s a writer’s group in my town, so I’m going to seek it out and hope it works for me (and I for them).

  2. I’m a big fan of Writers groups – I think they are the single best tool a writer can have.

    I’m a member of an online one that is quite good – It’s not like the usual online circles, where everyone posts a variation of ‘Nice story, you can find mine at X’ – We dish out very detailed critiques when we have the time, and there is all sorts of discussion related to writing – and everything else. It’s more of a community than anything else. Not only can you get a lot of feedback, but critiquing others teaches you a lot about writing itself.

    I’ve been meaning to attend a meeting of my uni writing club, but I always talk myself out of it. The first one of the year was today, and I didn’t go because I had no classes on today. Next week, I have one on a Friday, so I’ll check it out.

    • If you do get a chance to make that meeting with your writing club, I think it would be great. It took me a while to find a good group of people, but it all started with going to that first meeting. Good luck!

  3. Pingback: Your honest opinion please | Fifty Shades of Tribute - Sasha Cameron

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s